3' x 4', welded steel frame...critique wanted! - Page 2


Page 2 of 2 FirstFirst 12
Results 21 to 27 of 27

Thread: 3' x 4', welded steel frame...critique wanted!

  1. #21
    Member peteeng's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2018
    Location
    dum dum
    Posts
    6248
    Downloads
    0
    Uploads
    0

    Default Re: 3' x 4', welded steel frame...critique wanted!

    Hi Mactec - I agree that VSR can crack structures. Tabs and small cantilevered areas can freely vibrate and over deflect and crack in my experience too, even with thick structures. That's one reason a modal analysis is first done to establish if there are areas of concern. With the mining equipment VSR small pieces are tacked or clamped onto ram mounts and areas of concern or experience to stop them from getting over excited at resonance.

    All processes require a good understanding of how it works & its pitfalls. Horses for courses... As a note - we are not really concerned about the internal stress of a structure this is in equilibrium and will not affect the performance of a machine,. We are really concerned about making a correctly dimensioned machine. So the TSR or VSR or peening or whatever is used is a step along the way that allows the maker to get to a satisfactory dimensional result. As you have said you can fabricate stuff and hit the required dimensional spec. This can be done in a repeat environment as the people learn along the way how to get a result., The hobby maker has one shot at it so they only learn about this stuff once and correct it once... Hopefully the forum stores & transmits some useful knowledge to short circuit some grief... Peter



  2. #22
    Member mactec54's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2005
    Location
    USA
    Posts
    15362
    Downloads
    0
    Uploads
    0

    Default Re: 3' x 4', welded steel frame...critique wanted!

    Quote Originally Posted by peteeng View Post
    Hi Mactec - I agree that VSR can crack structures. Tabs and small cantilevered areas can freely vibrate and over deflect and crack in my experience too, even with thick structures. That's one reason a modal analysis is first done to establish if there are areas of concern. With the mining equipment VSR small pieces are tacked or clamped onto ram mounts and areas of concern or experience to stop them from getting over excited at resonance.

    All processes require a good understanding of how it works & its pitfalls. Horses for courses... As a note - we are not really concerned about the internal stress of a structure this is in equilibrium and will not affect the performance of a machine,. We are really concerned about making a correctly dimensioned machine. So the TSR or VSR or peening or whatever is used is a step along the way that allows the maker to get to a satisfactory dimensional result. As you have said you can fabricate stuff and hit the required dimensional spec. This can be done in a repeat environment as the people learn along the way how to get a result., The hobby maker has one shot at it so they only learn about this stuff once and correct it once... Hopefully the forum stores & transmits some useful knowledge to short circuit some grief... Peter
    The only problem with these stress relieving processes, is if there is any machining needed then Heat Treating is the best as every part of the structure is stress free before machining

    The machine frame I was talking about was a one off that I fabricated it in my home shop, so would be comparable to what any Hobby builder could do, I will be doing another one soon so may do a thread on it, threads take time and I usually don't have much of that, anything is possible if the builder thinks about the process before they attack, one misplaced or incorrect weld procedure can mess up the whole build

    Mactec54


  3. #23
    Member Matthew_H's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2022
    Posts
    5
    Downloads
    0
    Uploads
    0

    Default Re: 3' x 4', welded steel frame...critique wanted!

    Thanks everyone!

    I've made a whole lot of progress, and spent a lot more money.

    A small change: I beefed up the ends of the gantry with a big slab of 6" x 2" C-channel.

    That's the only change to the design that I've made.

    Got a buddy who's a welder to do the frame for me.

    Then another buddy and I did the gantry ourselves. (Forgot to get pictures of the gantry.)

    Then I got both pieces (frame and gantry) stress-relieved at a heat treatment facility. I didn't know what to expect for the cost of that, but was pleasantly surprised.

    Then I got the base frame machined at a machine shop...they were able to hook the whole thing into a big mill and mill it all at once, so the X-axis rail beds are straight, parallel, and flat. And they drilled and tapped the holes. (The machining cost was horrifying; that's why it took a while to get it done.) They did say, however, that having the thermal stress-relief done was a huge help.

    There is a weird feature to my X-axis rails...they are counterbored for socket head cap screws, but the counterbores aren't actually wide enough to accept a standard SHCS screwhead. I had to turn all 36 screwheads down on a lathe to get them to fit.

    Then I took the gantry to our local makerspace and machined it myself on a Bridgeport. I doubt it's perfect, but I haven't drilled/tapped the rail holes yet, and I can't exactly tell how well I did until the rails are bolted on.

    Next up: finish the gantry, build the Z, start wiring. Seems easy enough.

    Attached Thumbnails Attached Thumbnails 3' x 4', welded steel frame...critique wanted!-end-jpg   3' x 4', welded steel frame...critique wanted!-pxl_20220312_222009183-jpg   3' x 4', welded steel frame...critique wanted!-pxl_20220313_011350705-jpg   3' x 4', welded steel frame...critique wanted!-pxl_20220313_015507888-jpg  

    3' x 4', welded steel frame...critique wanted!-pxl_20221010_142017663-jpg   3' x 4', welded steel frame...critique wanted!-pxl_20221010_173836096-jpg   3' x 4', welded steel frame...critique wanted!-pxl_20221010_215204112-jpg   3' x 4', welded steel frame...critique wanted!-pxl_20221019_004505052-jpg  



  4. #24
    Member peteeng's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2018
    Location
    dum dum
    Posts
    6248
    Downloads
    0
    Uploads
    0

    Default Re: 3' x 4', welded steel frame...critique wanted!

    Hi Matt - The holes and counterbore are correct size. They are for the screw size down so there is adjustment in the rail. Looks good. Peter



  5. #25
    Member Matthew_H's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2022
    Posts
    5
    Downloads
    0
    Uploads
    0

    Default Re: 3' x 4', welded steel frame...critique wanted!

    The Z axis went together really well. Again I have access to a manual mill through my local makerspace, so I was able to drill all the necessary holes in both plates and both spacers quite precisely. No alignment issues at all.

    Attached Thumbnails Attached Thumbnails 3' x 4', welded steel frame...critique wanted!-router_zaxis1-jpg  


  6. #26
    Member Matthew_H's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2022
    Posts
    5
    Downloads
    0
    Uploads
    0

    Default Re: 3' x 4', welded steel frame...critique wanted!

    Here are a few photos of the X-axis motor mounts. There is a little spacer between the frame and the motor mount, due to the imprecision of the welding. A bit of aluminum to use as a shim is all it needed. Ball screws are installed. (The bearings on the opposite end of the ball screws are mounted similarly to the motor mounts.)

    Attached Thumbnails Attached Thumbnails 3' x 4', welded steel frame...critique wanted!-x-motor-1_small-jpg   3' x 4', welded steel frame...critique wanted!-x-motor-2_small-jpg  


  7. #27
    Member Matthew_H's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2022
    Posts
    5
    Downloads
    0
    Uploads
    0

    Default Re: 3' x 4', welded steel frame...critique wanted!

    The y-axis was the part of this design that had me the most nervous. Alignment issues in the X or Z, whether with the screws or the rails or both, could be fixed with shims. The screw on the y-axis had to be right the first time.

    I used the manual mill to drill the holes for the y-axis (gantry) rails. It was really tricky because I had to clamp the gantry to the table, drill the holes, then unclamp and flip it over, reclamp it down, and drill the new holes...and they had to align perfectly. I got lucky with all that though, and it worked out. The screw was going to be a lot harder.

    I used some aluminum blocks to mount the screw bearings; this was so that, if I messed up the alignment, I only had to make new aluminum blocks, and not a whole new gantry.

    I installed the screw but left the bearings unattached, so it was just connected by the Z axis. Then I rolled the Z axis all the way to one side, and used some clamps to temporarily fasten the block to the gantry on that end. Then I rolled it to the other end and clamped the other bearing. I adjusted everything a few times to make sure the bearings were located right, then I drilled through the blocks and the gantry and bolted it up.

    It actually worked, so I'm pretty excited about that.

    So:
    - the frame and the gantry are welded, leveled, and drilled for rails
    - the z axis is built and assembled
    - the rails and screws are attached to both the frame and the gantry
    - the z axis is installed on the gantry

    Next:
    - get the motors attached and the shaft couplings in
    - wire it up
    - turn it on

    Attached Thumbnails Attached Thumbnails 3' x 4', welded steel frame...critique wanted!-pxl_20230105_215947900_small_small-jpg   3' x 4', welded steel frame...critique wanted!-pxl_20230228_030648493_small_small-jpg   3' x 4', welded steel frame...critique wanted!-pxl_20230301_055617562_small_small-jpg   3' x 4', welded steel frame...critique wanted!-pxl_20230301_055625724_small_small-jpg  

    3' x 4', welded steel frame...critique wanted!-pxl_20230301_055640454_small_small-jpg   3' x 4', welded steel frame...critique wanted!-pxl_20230301_055712304_small-jpg  


Page 2 of 2 FirstFirst 12

Tags for this Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  


About CNCzone.com

    We are the largest and most active discussion forum for manufacturing industry. The site is 100% free to join and use, so join today!

Follow us on


Our Brands

3' x 4', welded steel frame...critique wanted!

3' x 4', welded steel frame...critique wanted!