Is a Tormach capable of making this part in small production qtys? - Page 4


Page 4 of 4 FirstFirst 1234
Results 61 to 77 of 77

Thread: Is a Tormach capable of making this part in small production qtys?

  1. #61
    Member
    Join Date
    Oct 2017
    Posts
    40
    Downloads
    0
    Uploads
    0

    Default Re: Is a Tormach capable of making this part in small production qtys?

    Quote Originally Posted by jgraves View Post
    The Minimill EDU is not just a discounted price for schools, it also is missing a bunch of features that limit it's productivity (no ATC, 4000rpm, etc). I actually think the Tormach (770 or 1100, optioned up to the same price) would be more productive in most cases.
    It's only missing the 6k spindle, coolant pump, and 10 tool ATC. Once you add those items back, your price comes to $25,880 before shipping, so a savings of $5k to get the exact same thing as the standard Mini Mill. Still a smokin deal in my opinion..



  2. #62
    Registered
    Join Date
    Jul 2007
    Location
    Canada
    Posts
    12
    Downloads
    0
    Uploads
    0

    Default Re: Is a Tormach capable of making this part in small production qtys?

    Quote Originally Posted by CadRhino View Post
    When the stars are aligned and everything seems to be working, I occasionally go inside and have dinner whije the machine is running. Some times I have come back to an atc crash, though.
    I have also had my Tormach machine through the night several times but it was with no tool changes, just one tool doing a big 3D part.
    I think you will need to spend in the $100k plus range to get what you are looking for.

    The tormach is a great first machine or hobby machine and it has allowed me to learn and make parts. If I ever feel like I can get the atc to work reliably, I actually think about adding another one to my shop. I will probably get a different/bigger machine to add instead.
    I'm not sure about $100k plus but way more than $25k is becoming a more serious consideration.

    I've used enough industrial tools to understand the difference between good consumer grade and industrial grade tools. I have a manual mill and lathe that I'd place in the good, large, hobby class of machine (1.5 to 2hp, roughly 1000 pounds each). I've made some fairly impressive parts on both but the lathe lacks power and the mill lacks rigidity for some of the projects I've done.

    I have a friend about an hour away with a fairly basic 1100 that I have to go run some parts on. Hopefully that will help make the decision clear.



  3. #63
    Member
    Join Date
    Jun 2005
    Location
    USA
    Posts
    653
    Downloads
    0
    Uploads
    0

    Default Re: Is a Tormach capable of making this part in small production qtys?

    Far more of an issue than power reliability is cutting tools break and wear, no matter how much the machine cost. I know commercial shops that run lights-out (mostly a bunch of little parts rather than one huge one), but they are always prepared to come in the morning to see reject parts and broken tools. Unless you probe the tool every toolchange, once one breaks, you can be in a world of hurt real fast if following tools rely on features supposedly cut by a broken one.

    Friend in the repair business said he fixed a HAAS a couple weeks ago from when the entire toolchanger carousel dropped onto the table overnight. Stuff happens.

    I leave my Tormach with ATC running for an hour or so by itself on proven code which is about as long as my code runs anyway.



  4. #64
    Member Steve Seebold's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2009
    Location
    USA and proud of it
    Posts
    1863
    Downloads
    0
    Uploads
    0

    Default Re: Is a Tormach capable of making this part in small production qtys?

    I would make 2 fixtures that hold 6 parts each. Make them exactly the same and if you do your pargram right, every time your program sees M30 you'll have 6 finished parts.

    I'll be happy to help if your programming software won't do it.

    I could do make those parts on my 1100 using Mach III, but I don't have the ATC on my machine. The ATC wasn't available when I bought my machine.

    I bought my machine for hobby use and something to do in my retirement. I figured for $4,200.00 I could change the tool a whole bunch of times by hand.

    As I said above, I am still running Mach III and to date it has never let me down. No run away moves, it has run flawlessly for between 6 ant 7 thousand hours.

    You can buy GOOD PARTS or you can buy CHEAP PARTS, but you can't buy GOOD CHEAP PARTS.


  5. #65
    Registered javanree's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2011
    Location
    Netherlands
    Posts
    35
    Downloads
    10
    Uploads
    0

    Default Re: Is a Tormach capable of making this part in small production qtys?

    Quote Originally Posted by jgraves View Post
    We have a Stratasys Fortus 250mc running on an APC SMT2200 UPS. Looking at the specs (8 minutes at 1920W), it will probably run the 770 and controller. There is also a SMT3000 which would run the 770, controller and monitor even with the spindle maxed. I'd go with the SMT3000 if you are typically close by when running the mill and don't want to automate a safe shutdown on power failure. Having the monitor on the UPS assists you in manually shutting down the mill if the power failure last for several minutes. Obviously how hard you are pushing the mill will determine how long the battery will last.
    Such UPS units won't like things like VFD's connected to it. I'd seek some expert advice before plugging in a CNC machine, you might otherwise kill the UPS. Also a UPS doesn't always give a nice sine wave output (most APC SMART models do) which might cause issues, so beware.



  6. #66
    Member
    Join Date
    Aug 2016
    Location
    United States
    Posts
    39
    Downloads
    0
    Uploads
    0

    Default Is a Tormach capable of making this part in small production qtys?

    I heard possibly pathpilot 4 probing for tool breakage. Any truth behind it? When Pathpilot supports it I will pull the trigger on an atc. The only thing that would push me over the edge in getting an atc would being able to run lights out. I don’t have a worry in running lights out with a fully loaded pallet which only uses 1 tool.

    Regarding maintenance on a Tormach for the 25k you spend you are agreeing to no onsite support and you are expected to service the machine. Phone support for Tormach is amazing though and they stock a lot of parts so typically no wait for a boat from China. If this doesn’t play well with you then get the haas and expect $1500 service calls and very expensive machine parts which is expected since they have to somehow pay an extensive haas onsite tech dept. even with the haas mini mill I feel we are comparing apples and oranges. Industrial level support and dependability with that haas mini vs consumer focused with a Tormach which is able to really be pushed and pushed hard but still consumer focused. Personally I am leaning towards adding another 1100 or maybe 2 as I continue to grow vs getting a single super fast vmc.


    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

    Last edited by cncbuilt; 10-21-2017 at 05:52 PM.


  7. #67
    Registered
    Join Date
    Apr 2015
    Posts
    93
    Downloads
    0
    Uploads
    0

    Default Re: Is a Tormach capable of making this part in small production qtys?

    Motoeng,

    I cant answer whether it makes more sense to buy your own machine or not as it really depends on your vision for your business. I own a Tormach 1100 and a Haas VF-2SSYT. If you are just looking to make 5-10 parts before committing to a production run the Tormach would make sense, but if you want to do any level of production yourself I would skip the Tormach and look at something along the lines of a Haas minimill at minimum. The Tormach even with ATC is not a production machine and long term it will not save you money. Sometimes owning your machine is more than just a clear cut financial decisions, there are many opportunities that can come up when you own your own machine. Personally I enjoy having machines and being able to make my own stuff. It's more than just a clear cut financial decision, but owning them has brought me a lot of opportunities and gives you so much potential.

    Last edited by Gilmax; 10-23-2017 at 01:07 AM.


  8. #68
    Member
    Join Date
    Aug 2013
    Posts
    980
    Downloads
    0
    Uploads
    0

    Default

    Gilmax, you are in a good position to give the OP a real apples to oranges comparison of what the differences between a tormach and larger commercial machine.
    I love my Tormach ((sans ATC issues) and see it like this;
    - Speed; a vf2 is much more rigid and has 10x the hp so it will really be fast.
    - Accuracy l; the tormach r8 spindle is prone to have runout of +\-.003. One can lap the collet and get this number tighter probably. The vf2 will be much more accurate.
    - Reliability; I have already posted some of my ATC reliability issues. I have read that the smaller haas umbrella style atc’s Can have issues but the vf2 with side mount vertical atc’s seem really reliable.

    It comes down to you get pretty much what you pay for.
    I am glad I got my feet wet with a tormach. I can now appreciate the difference more.


    QUOTE=Gilmax;2107116]Motoeng,

    I cant answer whether it makes more sense to buy your own machine or not as it really depends on your vision for your business. I own a Tormach 1100 and a Haas VF-2SSYT. If you are just looking to make 5-10 parts before committing to a production run the Tormach would make sense, but if you want to do any level of production yourself I would skip the Tormach and look at something along the lines of a Haas minimill at minimum. The Tormach even with ATC is not a production machine and long term it will not save you money. Sometimes owning your machine is more than just a clear cut financial decisions, there are many opportunities that can come up when you own your own machine. Personally I enjoy having machines and being able to make my own stuff. It's more than just a clear cut financial decision, but owning them has brought me a lot of opportunities and gives you so much potential.[/QUOTE]



  9. #69
    Member mountaindew's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2007
    Location
    earth
    Posts
    2151
    Downloads
    0
    Uploads
    0

    Default Re: Is a Tormach capable of making this part in small production qtys?

    Motoeng,

    First off my Tormach mill is a versatile tool with decent accuracy.
    After reading this thread I would mention that a cnc mill is one part of a shop. I sometimes forget that I have a 600 sqft clean climate controlled area for those machines and me to work in. That space also includes a power panel with dedicated power outlets for all these precision tools and outlets for a host of support tools that are also required for mills and other tools. Things like band saws, air compressors, buffers,grinders, tumblers.......all require power and work space. Then you move on to tool storage and all those little measurement and other precision shiny things that cost about half as much as a Tormach mill. Move up to a Haas mill and that cost again goes up to match. Then after all this stuff is in place and working you need to use it! I dont know about other people around here, but in my experience this is a perishable skill. If you dont use cad/cam software often you will struggle to get things done right the first time. If you dont use these machines often, imho the machines atrophy a little and dont always work as expected after setting for weeks.The same applies to skills when operating these machines. Like operating aircraft, shooting guns, or racing motorcycles, my machinist skills seam to degrade in a short period of time. Not hard to get everything back up to speed but it takes time either way.
    Giggle, my neighbor was amazed by what it took just to turn it on and get it ready to do anything



  10. #70
    Member
    Join Date
    May 2016
    Location
    United States
    Posts
    138
    Downloads
    0
    Uploads
    0

    Default Re: Is a Tormach capable of making this part in small production qtys?

    Quote Originally Posted by Steve Seebold View Post
    I would make 2 fixtures that hold 6 parts each. Make them exactly the same and if you do your pargram right, every time your program sees M30 you'll have 6 finished parts.
    This is exactly what I do, even down to the number!

    This takes 2 - 9" long bars (less cutting) and when done I end up with 6 pieces finished machining and ready for finishing (tumbler, bead blast then anodize)

    I can run 2 vises with a fixture in each. with the miteebite stuff I dont even take the fixtures out. Just pop out the finished pieces, vacuum them off quick, put new stock in and run the program again. I dont have an ATC, but have the PDB, So I need to be around for tool changes, but they are super quick. I have a IP camera pointing at the machine so I can keep an eye on it via a cheap tablet if I have to run upstairs.

    And like mountaindew said, there are so many other things to do around the shop while the machine is running that no ATC hasnt been an issue for me.





  11. #71
    Member
    Join Date
    May 2016
    Location
    United States
    Posts
    138
    Downloads
    0
    Uploads
    0

    Default Re: Is a Tormach capable of making this part in small production qtys?

    They key to making the most of your time will be creative fixturing. It will be a larger cost up front, but worth it in the end if the extra cost can be justified.



  12. #72
    Member Steve Seebold's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2009
    Location
    USA and proud of it
    Posts
    1863
    Downloads
    0
    Uploads
    0

    Default Re: Is a Tormach capable of making this part in small production qtys?

    To answer your question directly, yes the Tormach is quite capable of running your parts in small quantities. I'd say quantities of 25 or less would be no problem.

    If you plan on running hundreds or thousands of pieces, then obviously the Tormach isn't the machine for you.

    I'm getting ready to set up a job that's only 30 pieces, but I have run the job before so I'll going to take a chance this time and double the order.

    I had a customer when I had my shop that I us d to get a teal nice little (small parts) job from. They would order 200 pieces at a time and it never failed, after about 10 days and want 10 more pieces.

    Now mind you, this was about a $12.00 part in 200 piece quantities, but I had a $350.00 minimum order and they would always go for it.

    When I ran the second order I ran 25 extra pieces and delivered 200. My customer didn't let me down. About a week after I delivered 200 pieces they called and wanted 12 more. I reminded them about my $350.00 minimum and told them I would deliver their parts on Friday. Then, Friday morning I made an invoice for $350.00, pulled 12 $12.00 parts off the shelf and delivered them.

    Eventually I had enough parts on the shelf that I would just pull parts from stock and deliver them.

    Then I had a heart attack in the shop and sold the company when my wife decided I no longer needed the stress of ownership.

    Last edited by Steve Seebold; 10-26-2017 at 08:56 AM.


  13. #73
    Member
    Join Date
    Oct 2017
    Posts
    40
    Downloads
    0
    Uploads
    0

    Default Re: Is a Tormach capable of making this part in small production qtys?

    Really appreciate all the excellent replies! I guess the bottom line for me is that in order to get the surface finish I require for these parts, the threading and profile will require turning. Even if place the parts in the spindle, I will still have to thread mill, adding yet another op, and I seriously doubt thread milling will provide as good a surface funish as turning. That pretty much kills the idea of getting a mini mill (if I could afford one) as I’d still need a lathe. While it seems like the Tormach won’t buy me complete independence from my machine shop, it will provide some options to help my business grow, at a relatively affordable cost. I’m also leaning more toward the 770 as opposed to the 1100 given that I only work in aluminum.



  14. #74
    Member
    Join Date
    Feb 2006
    Location
    USA
    Posts
    7063
    Downloads
    0
    Uploads
    0

    Default Re: Is a Tormach capable of making this part in small production qtys?

    Quote Originally Posted by motoeng View Post
    Even if place the parts in the spindle, I will still have to thread mill, adding yet another op, and I seriously doubt thread milling will provide as good a surface funish as turning.
    Wrong on both counts. First, putting the part in the spindle, you can cut using a lathe tool, so finish will be EXACTLY the same as with a lathe. Second, IMHO, threadmilling beats a lathe hands-down for finish quality, and you can easily tune for a very precise fit.

    Regards,
    Ray L.



  15. #75
    Member
    Join Date
    Oct 2017
    Posts
    40
    Downloads
    0
    Uploads
    0

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by SCzEngrgGroup View Post
    Wrong on both counts. First, putting the part in the spindle, you can cut using a lathe tool, so finish will be EXACTLY the same as with a lathe. Second, IMHO, threadmilling beats a lathe hands-down for finish quality, and you can easily tune for a very precise fit.

    Regards,
    Ray L.
    Thx for the input Ray. I understand you’ll get the same finish as turning when vmc turning. My comment reg surface finish was specifically directed at thread milling. I’ve seen thread milling, and it looks painfully slow to me, but maybe I just haven’t seen it done right.

    Regardless, I still think turning this part is the better way to go. I can turn the outer profile, bottom hole, and threads without having to change setups. Vmc turning and thread milling will require two different setups.



  16. #76
    Member
    Join Date
    Aug 2013
    Posts
    980
    Downloads
    0
    Uploads
    0

    Default

    Threadmilling is much better in all ways and just a little bit slower but it gives you awesome control and finish.

    QUOTE=motoeng;2108652]Thx for the input Ray. I understand you’ll get the same finish as turning when vmc turning. My comment reg surface finish was specifically directed at thread milling. I’ve seen thread milling, and it looks painfully slow to me, but maybe I just haven’t seen it done right.

    Regardless, I still think turning this part is the better way to go. I can turn the outer profile, bottom hole, and threads without having to change setups. Vmc turning and thread milling will require two different setups.[/QUOTE]



  17. #77
    Member
    Join Date
    Jun 2012
    Location
    USA
    Posts
    311
    Downloads
    0
    Uploads
    0

    Default Re: Is a Tormach capable of making this part in small production qtys?

    Quote Originally Posted by motoeng View Post
    . ...Vmc turning and thread milling will require two different setups.
    If you add a spindle position sensor (once per rotation sensor) then you can also turn the threads in the VMC spindle. Search this forum for vertical mill turning, someone that used to actively post here did it around 2010.



Page 4 of 4 FirstFirst 1234

Tags for this Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  


About CNCzone.com

    We are the largest and most active discussion forum for manufacturing industry. The site is 100% free to join and use, so join today!

Follow us on


Our Brands

Is a Tormach capable of making this part in small production qtys?

Is a Tormach capable of making this part in small production qtys?