oneCNC vs. Mastercam

[rickyt]

I feel that MCX is light years beyond V9.1, and mr2 has came out and add alot of new cool features. Yes I own MC and I have used is it for years. I was really looking hard at OneCnc but I went with the one that I am use to, so their was no learning curve. I opened my own shop and was looking at other cam setups, but I was afraid of the learning curve of a new cam system. Learning a new software was the last thing I needed when starting my own company, I needed instant production. Although OneCnc was my second choice, I my end up buying it anyway, it may do some things easier than MC, it never hurts to try, hey its only money right.

[robinsoncr]

This is a good thread. I have MastercamX Router Level 1 MR2. I have been racking my head about what to do. We are adding a 4th axis to our Thermwood cnc router and I want to start using the router to carve guitar bodies and furniture parts. But I'm finding that I will probably have to upgrade from Router Level 1 to Router Level 3 plus add Solids to be able to machine surfaces like those found on an electric guitar.

That's a big chunk of change. I have ran the gauntlet from looking at Rhino3d with Deskproto, Rhino3d with Madcam etc. The problem is that I'm used to Mastercam X's interface. I can't seem to get a grip on Rhino3d. Plus, when you look at how you place geometry in order to be machined on the cnc, it's much easier in Mastercam. Or at least, I know what I'm doing there.

OneCNC has sent me their pricing for their products. But now, I'd be faced with re-learning a new cad system. How does it compare to Mastercam Router? Mastercam Router has nesting (not advanced nesting), MDF door wizards, Stair runner wizards and pretty decent tool strategies. But getting to the place where I can machine surfaces, that's where I hit the wall. Any suggestions? Advice? I asked Mastercam if I could sell my seat since it's not really working for what I need now but I haven't rec'd a straight yes or no answer. And I have to admit, I hate those yearly maintenance fees!

Thanks for listening,

Chris

[cadcam]

Chris to do the work you need you do not have to add solids and you need at least router Pro to do multisurface.

The cost is no more then you tring to by a new seat of ONEcnc.
Have you talked with your dealer about this?

I design electric guitar for local customer here were i live and we use mc to cut them.

[REVCAM_Bob]

Hey you guys, look for my thread about the "challenge for all" and lets see some of you
guys program the sample block.... It might help you guys to time this process and help
determine how different programs handle it??

[robinsoncr]

Cadcam, I have talked to my MC reseller. They are very good people to deal with. I asked him to work up some numbers for me. I remember that back when I was purchasing my cnc that Router Pro was quoted at like $24k. I've gone back through and looked through my emails but can't find it.

Anyway, they told me that they would work with me on the price and allow me a 30 day trial to see how it works. I have gone through the data on MC's website about the differences between Router and Router Pro. I thought that originally, with Router Pro you got the true shape nesting and other features besides a enabling a few surface toolpaths.

About the solids module. Do you feel it makes it 'easier' to program parts like this? What's the advantages vs. disadvantages of having the solids module? I know the one disadvantage would be the exta $1k. Feel free to email me, I'd really like to talk more.

Thanks,

Chris Robinson
chris.tcc@earthlink.net