BobCAD-CAM V20 vs. Rhino3D + RhinoCAM

[haysys]

Hello All,

Neophyte here. I'm in the process of converting a square-column Industrial Hobbies mill and have been reading as much as I can in order to make a good decision on CAD-CAM software. MACH2/3 will be controlling the machine.

Based on what I have read and budget limitations, I have narrowed the field to BobCAD-CAM V20 and Rhino 3D + RhinoCAM (but totally open to seeing the errors of my thinking). I would like all of your informed opinions on the merits of one compared to the other. And, if you think I've missed the boat, please recommend another product I should consider.

I've been lurking outside most every CNCZone window there is for sometime, and want to acknowledge you all for constructing a truly vibrant community, and look forward to being a more active part of it!!

BTW, I just received an offer from Bobcad promoting two seats of BobCAD-CAM V20 & BaobART Pro for $995+shipping. Offer expires April 22nd. Seems like a good deal to me, and is cerrtainly nudging me toward Bobcad.

David

[ger21]

What type of parts will you be making? There might be cheaper alternatives. SheetCAM and MeshCAM with Rhino, or any cheap CAD software. SheetCAM + MeshCAM + TurboCAD = ~$400 It depends a little on what you want to do, though.

[haysys]

ger21,

I'll be doing various types of work. Some 2D templates, some 3D engraving and sculpting to make dies for use in hydraulic press, some 4 axis work, and some mechanical design and engineering work for projects yet unseen but discussed with fellow conspirators.

I've been using AutoCAD LT for years (current ver is 2002) for simple 2d work, but expect the usefulness of that app will hit the wall with any 3D work.

I tend to invest in tools that will not constrain my abilities (as in give me the opportunity to fail completely, rather complain about the quality of my tools). And, I prefer to learn one or two tools very well rather than several tools well enough to get by. Too many years of steep learning curves I expect.

Thanks,

David

[ger21]

I haven't used BobCAD, but I personally would go the Rhino - RhinoCAM route. You might want to look at Alibre, and Visual Mill Basic (same as RhinoCAM), might be a better option for mechanical design.

[HuFlungDung]

David,
I'd recommend that you look at OneCNC. There are several packages to choose from, meaning you can upgrade from one to the next, as your skills grow and the need arises.

Some guys might think OneCNC is overkill, but in all seriousness, there is nothing else I would start out with, if I knew I wanted to make parts for a living. The only exception would be if I was simply going to cut profiles with a laser or something. It is possible to get by with less, but, you won't enjoy it

OneCNC will do profiling, too, but they've actually got software for handling those specific needs as well.

OneCNC's no-nonsense approach lets you easily be creative with the ways you might want to try to cut your parts.

I often make a program up, run it, and observe the way it all pans out when run once on the cnc. It is so very easy to decide to change a tool type for better performance, change the toolpaths etc. Its actually fun. It actually turns your computer into a productive tool.

I could rave on and on, but anyways, set up an online demo with the guys at OneCNC in Florida. If nothing else, its fantastic to know what the real world has to work with.

[JavaDog]

Originally Posted by HuFlungDung David, I'd recommend that you look at OneCNC. There are several packages to choose from, meaning you can upgrade from one to the next, as your skills grow and the need arises.

Which is exactly what I am doing. Buying Express to start, then as my business and needs grow - I will be upgading to Professional so I can do everything (modeling included) ina single package. Iwas very impressed with XR when I had my demo...I was actually online with them from 8:30 - 10:00.

'Course, that isn't what you asked...but you know what they say about opinions!

[haysys]

Gerry, HuFlung and JavaDog,

Thanks so much for your thoughts and input. I've been poking around in the OneCNC, Alibre and Visual Mill sites, and looking more seriously at some of those options. It's gonna take some serious play with eval and demo software to make an informed decision. I truly want to make this decision only once.

JavaDog, do you feel like sharing a ballpark figure of what the OneCNC Express ver cost you?? The reviews I read sure do give it high marks. Sounds like if I can afford the freight, I will not be dissapointed.

The Alibre app sure seems to have a lot of admirers here too. A CAM app would still be required; Does Visual Mill Basic seem like a good match with Alibre??

Again, thanks for your time and attention.

[JavaDog]

Originally Posted by haysys JavaDog, do you feel like sharing a ballpark figure of what the OneCNC Express ver cost you?? The reviews I read sure do give it high marks. Sounds like if I can afford the freight, I will not be dissapointed.

Let me put it this way, it is competitive with VisualMill Basic 5.0.
Best bet is to set up an online demo. Other than when I called the sales rep after the demo, I haven't heard a peep back from them - they are waiting on me to decided to buy (which I have).

[bgriggs]

Onecnc stupid question of the day:

I went to their website and noticed three basic products segments, mill, lathe and profiler.

Q: Do you get all of these when you buy their package or are they each separate modules?


Bill

[masterblaster]

I don't have any experience with BobCad, but from I've gathered from from other designers, it's a bit connstricted and a little dated. Rhino is excellant for 3-d modeling, especially free form nurb based stuff. Great for dies and molds for detailed stuff. If you are just doing geometric stuff them maybe another pakage would suit you better. Maybe solidworks? I know Rhino is relativly cheep, Say about 5bills. It is a great deal at that price and a very powerful tool. It can design 3-d surfaces way down to 1/10 of a tenth. It works well with most file types excepting for importing stl files.I use it reg and can do anything with it.

[ChrisJ]

Hi Dave,

Just one more option when considering OneCNC Express. They sell there 3D modeler (Solid Creator) as a separate product if one were elect to go that route. I have no idea what they charge for that package. Maybe it is similar to Alibre or RhinoCAD in price. Just something to think about for a 3D modeler.

I have Alibre as well. Great product. Will only get better as time goes on. But I haven't spent much time modeling with it, I have been concentrating my efforts on modeling in OneCNC and I am enjoying it very much.

I have the Expert version so I have all the goodies. If all the modeling features are included in the solid creator as in the Expert series, it will most likely meet all your modeling needs.

Like Hu mentioned, you have the ability to upgrade as your needs increase with OneCNC. They have a great help forum! Also a MAJOR plus.

CNC is new to me as well. I also purchased the Industrial hobbies mill with a conversion kit. I will be driving it with Mach2/3. Still assemblying it though.

One more point. No annual maintenance fees. Only charges for major upgrades.

Chris

[Halfnutz]

Is the bobcad ver 17 for 395 a complete waste of my money?