Servo tuning without an O-scope

[southernexplore]

Is there somwhere I can go to read up on tuning servo drives (G320X)?
Thanks,
Tommy

Similar Threads:

• Selecting the correct Fanuc VCU for a servo (Plus Servo error & Tuning)
• Tuning with and old-school O-Scope
• Need Help!- G320 motor tuning issue with Fluke 124 scope
• G 320 tuning w/scope
• Tuning Servos with out an O-scope?

[Loadedagain]

good question tommy!

i spent some time recently tuning my 320's by ear and they seem to be working well... my motors were humming like crazy and i don't have access to an oscilloscope so there wasn't an option for me. i spoke to the manufacturer of my milling machine. he said that's how they tune them! so... i fine tuned damping and gain til they were quiet. 40 hours of machining and they're ok. i'd be interested to know if this will bite me later on.

[southernexplore]

I have an oscilloscope but I do not like the idea of having to dismount them to tune them. Seems like the test points would be located on the outside for ease of tuning, or at least the cover screws would be on the top instead of the bottom.

Tommy

[Mariss Freimanis]

Tommy,

Sorry. I agree with you. The package is a PIA to get access to test points and to change switch settings. We are working on it.

Mariss

[lancut]

Tommy,

Sorry. I agree with you. The package is a PIA to get access to test points and to change switch settings. We are working on it.

Mariss

... and nothing changed since!.. I won't recommend G320X to anyone anymore.