Router Using 3/4" MDF (first router build)

[eguy208]

A couple months ago, a co-worker told me about his CNC machine he built at home. He answered A LOT of my questions on the general building process and I then began searching online for more designs, tips and tricks.

I finally embarked on my very first router. If anything seems wrong, please let me know, I won't get offended, I'm here to get things right and learn.

Here's a list of specs:

-Material used is 3/4" MDF
-I'm using a HobbyCNC controller with 305 oz-in steppers
-I'm hoping to cut mainly wood and plastic, and maybe try aluminum.
-The guide shafts are 5/8" diameter.
-I'm using PTFE linear bearings, since they are cheap, I figured I could just upgrade if they didn't perform well. (so far they seem okay)
-I bought a porter cable router, but I think it will be too heavy for the machine, so I'm probably going to using a dremel instead
-The Z-axis has not been designed yet.
-The platform (for the workpiece) has not been assembled yet.
-I'm using 1/2 - 10 precision acme rod
-I don't have exact numbers for travel, but its roughly 36" x 36" x 4". The overall dimension of the machine is 41.5" x 41.5"

What do you guys think? Overall it seems pretty sturdy. I'm using wood glue and nails to secure the thing together. The thing is so big I had to build its own table. The table is 4' x 8', I tried to make it big enough to also support a desktop computer.










-Levino

[CarveOne]

eguy208,

Your machine is looking good. No problems that I can see so far.

I think that you will find that a Dremel tool shaft bearing flexes the plastic housing too much under heavy side loads and will cause chatter. Mine does when just using their router base attachments. Lots of people use the Dremels though. For fine detail work where small cutter bits are needed and speed isn't a factor the Dremel will work fine.

You can swap out the plastic bushings for bronze bushings, or you can modify the z axis assembly to install linear bearing blocks on the shafts. If the Porter Cable router is heavy enough to cause flexing in the y axis shafts near mid span, then something lighter like a trim router can be used.

CarveOne

[Mr.Chips]

Hi Eguy,

There may be a couple of potential problems with this design. I made the same mistake when I made the first version of my CNC.
The guide rods are not supported, you will be surprised how little weight it takes to deflect this metal, and the defelection will change from the center to the ends.
I notice your guide rails do not have a means of adjustment on the ends, no matter how hard you try and bore the guide rod mounting holes perfectly it is almost impossible to get them perfect, this will cause excess drag if they are out of alignment in any direction with these type bearings.

Don't give up, it is a fun project but there are certain rules that are hard to bend.

Hager

[eguy208]

Hi Eguy,

There may be a couple of potential problems with this design. I made the same mistake when I made the first version of my CNC.
The guide rods are not supported, you will be surprised how little weight it takes to deflect this metal, and the deflection will change from the center to the ends.
I notice your guide rails do not have a means of adjustment on the ends, no matter how hard you try and bore the guide rod mounting holes perfectly it is almost impossible to get them perfect, this will cause excess drag if they are out of alignment in any direction with these type bearings.

Don't give up, it is a fun project but there are certain rules that are hard to bend.

Hager

Yeah, I can tell the shafts are deflecting when I push on them. I was hoping it wouldn't cause too much trouble for me. When I get to the point were I'm needing fine detail, I think I'll be able to swap the lower guides out for supported shaft, that way I don't have to build a new machine. The deflection is also in the Y-axis, is it okay to use the supported shaft there as well? Or will the bearing not like being mounted sideways?

As far as shaft alignment, I haven't made those alignment blocks yet. I drilled the holes just big enough to slide the rods in and mount things up. I can tell there is a slight misalignment. My fix for now was to bore the holes bigger until the shafts weren't binding, and then add the alignment blocks.

Thanks for the comments, this is definitely a fun project that look forward to advancing.

-Levino

[harryn]

Nice start on a project - already further along than I am.

I am not sure about nails and MDF and vibration. Maybe screws would be more resistant to pulling out ? I assume the nails are there to hold it while the glue dries, which might be ok as well.

[eguy208]

Nice start on a project - already further along than I am.

I am not sure about nails and MDF and vibration. Maybe screws would be more resistant to pulling out ? I assume the nails are there to hold it while the glue dries, which might be ok as well.

Yes, all pieces are held together with carpenter's glue. The nails may provide extra strength, but mainly it allows me to keep working on the machine without having to wait for it to dry.

I'll probably add some screws later on just to be sure.

-Levino

[.xXACEXx.]

on useing a dremel..i was wanting to use a drimmel also..but was thinking of making a mount to remove the internals "the motor" taking all the plastic off the drimmel and replacing it with an aluminum "case"sort of mount them in a solid aluminum block this would make it super ridged i think....still just a thought nice looking build so far ,any reason you want a moving table vs. a moving gantry? (im still in the designing stage)

[eguy208]

any reason you want a moving table vs. a moving gantry? (im still in the designing stage)

I figured the less mass the steppers have to move, the easier it will be it making a sturdy structure. I'm sure you can see, moving the gantry would have been more mass then moving the workpiece.

A downside that I knew of, is the machine will need room to move it's X-axis. My next machine will mostly likely have a moving gantry.

-Levino

[Mr.Chips]

It is much easier to make a non moving gantry much more solid than a moving gantry. That is for the typical hobbist that doesn't have access to a machine shop full of equipment.
It is I guess cheaper also to build.

My 2 cents worth.

[dertsap]

Yeah, I can tell the shafts are deflecting when I push on them. I was hoping it wouldn't cause too much trouble for me.

-Levino

i tryed the same thing on my first setup but the weight of the gantry was too much for the rail so i cut some mdf and slid it under the rails on the x axis for support and used the skate bearing design , it made all the difference in the world , it would be a simple and effective mod for you at this point of the game

you can see what i mean in the pics
new biuld 24 x 48

[BobF]

Some have substituted a Proxon for the Dremel. I have no experience, but have not seen negative comments on this subistute.

[eguy208]

Made a little progress. I've got the acme rods installed (not the nuts though). I'm using shaft couplers to mount them to the motors. The workpiece platform is just laid in the machine and not mounted yet....it will be removable.




The MDF got chewed-up when making the motor mount hole. I didn't use clamps and the wood began vibrating and chewed up the hole. It still works, just looks like crap.




-Levino