Torq Cut 22 - Sound Check

[Marty_Escarcega]

Just as an update... I am highly considering pulling my z axis and doing a refresh. I had a bit of an accident (tossed a part via a facemill) and I now have a bit of a tick in my spindle at higher rpms. I was running it a bit and I think my axis are a bit louder than your guys. I got some estimates on rebuilding the ballscrews and they were in the $1-2k each range. I might just try to do end bearings because I have noise but no real backlash.

Richard

Bummer Richard,
You might post a new thread, so that MACTEC chimes in. I seem to remember his concern about ball screw alignment on the Z axis.
Sounds like its going to be quite a job. Keep us posted on your progress.
Take pics and video if you can for the rest of us in case we have to "cross that bridge"

Marty

[zane]

Just as an update... I am highly considering pulling my z axis and doing a refresh. I had a bit of an accident (tossed a part via a facemill) and I now have a bit of a tick in my spindle at higher rpms. I was running it a bit and I think my axis are a bit louder than your guys. I got some estimates on rebuilding the ballscrews and they were in the $1-2k each range. I might just try to do end bearings because I have noise but no real backlash.

Richard

My X axis was noisy but no backlash before I replaced the bearings. The ball screw is easy to tear down, clean and reassemble yourself. However if you are fitting new balls I could see the cost paying someone $1000 or so being justifiable.

[cooperjm]

I paid about $460 to have my ball screw service.

Sent from my SM-G955U using Tapatalk

[Marty_Escarcega]

I paid about $460 to have my ball screw service.

Who did your ballscrew service and what did they do to it and why did you send it in?
Marty

[cooperjm]

The wiper on the end of the nut was broken. They replaced the wiper and installed larger balls to take out backlash.

I sent the screw to Rand Industries, a part of Rockford ball screw.

I do not remember why I was looking around in there when I found the broken wiper. I also found the oil distribution block was corroded baldy. I replaced the block and the meters while I had it apart.

Sent from my SM-G955U using Tapatalk

[silviuib]

Hi, I know its been a while since the last post but I'm having a similar noise along my Y axes and was wondering how hard was it to change out the thrust bearings? Do you have to fully remove the shaft or can you just slide the bearings off?

[cooperjm]

If I remember correctly you're going to have to at least Slide the screw out far enough to get the bearings off the end.

Sent from my SM-G955U using Tapatalk

[silviuib]

Thanks for the reply. Are the bearings pressed on and do you need to indicate the shaft after reinstall?

[cooperjm]

Bearings are not pressed. Not sure about indicating it

Sent from my SM-G955U using Tapatalk