Hafco HM45 vs. Ozmestore HM45 copy - spindle motor power output?

[dvsU12]

Hi all,

Looking to purchase a HM45 sized mill in the next month or 2, in terms of supplier it's come down to Hare & Forbes here in Melbourne for $2095 (hoping to talk them down...) or (barring no other bids) Ozmestore's copy for $1495 + $270 for freight across to melbourne.

Obviously pricewise Ozmestore's offering is more attractive, however, their spindle motor is rated at only 0.75kw, whilst the HM45 from Hare & Forbes is rated at 1.1kw.

From memory, Ozmestore's offering has a slightly larger table too.

Is this 0.75kw motor going to be enough for the usual materials? (ie mild steel, SS, aluminium?)

Anything else i should be concerned about purchasing from Ozmestore in relation to warranty and the like?

Thanks

[gazza]

Hi, there is one other option in Melbourne, Standaco
http://www.standaco.com.au/page.asp?...3&productid=22
larger table, more "X" travel and theirs is 1.5KW
cheers
Gazza

[gazza]

I forgot to mention I have an excell spread sheet with all the models listed, not sure on how to post it here.
Gazza

[dvsU12]

Thanks Gazza, i do actually plan on dropping in to Standaco shortly to have a look at their DM45, however i'm hoping to get the mill for under $2k where possible.

[CrazyIvan]

I can highly recommend looking at Titan machinery.

And their ZAY7045FG (Motor: 1.5 kw, single-phase, 220V)

I purchased one of these recently and (although I'm just a beginner) it's a machine beyond my capabilities. CNC underway.

http://au.youtube.com/watch?v=8PQOQEJyO2w

http://au.youtube.com/watch?v=8PQOQEJyO2w

Look carefully at the accessories included with the machine.
My Titan included:

• 125mm machine vice
• 8pc collet chuck set
• Keyless drill chuck 1-13mm
• Stand
• Chip tray
• 58pc clamp set
• Face cutter
• Work lamp

The OzMe & Standaco offerings didn't include these, I wanted them anyway, and when I priced them separately, Titan was better value, and I hit the ground rolling.

I found Stuart very helpful both before and after the sale. He'll make an effort to find cost-effective shipping and you may well end up with more for your money than a local shop would provide.

It's also handy that they're all copies. I've gone 10min up the road to Hare & Forbes and gotten HM45 spares (broke the oil sight-glass).

[roohunt]

hi
the difference between the two is hare and forbes fully test run there machines and mesure the tables for strightness. ozmestore is pot luck off the pallet. hence cheeper price.
cheers

[CADScott]

The last machine I got from Hare & Forbes was still in the crate from Chine, they definately didn't test it or even open the crate!

Hare & Forbes have much higher overheads, with a massive warehouse and glossy catalogues compared to other online sellers. That is more likely the reason for the price difference.

[dvsU12]

Well, i guess to update an old thread, i ended up purchasing the DM45 from Standaco back in Jan, got it for a very good price. I would certainly recommend buying from them instead of Hafco.

[mozmozmoz]

Hmm, I've been wandering round the web today looking at cheap milling machines and wondering where to buy locally. So here's my summary.

Sold By	Model	Cost	X	Y	Z	Power	Weight	Spindle
www.mectek.com.au	DM130	750	220	100	130	350	50	MT3
TitanMachinery.com.au	TM16V	900	220	110		400	60	MT3
www.minitech.com.au	X2	1018	228	100	215	350	50	MT3
www.transquip.com.au	BMX2	1199	220	100		350	50	MT3⁄R8
TitanMachinery.com.au	TM20V	1639	350	160	50	600	140	MT2!
www.mectek.com.au	ZX 50F	1750	400	230	120	850	500	MT4
www.mectek.com.au	DM450AFG	1850	500	175	130	1100	325	MT4
www.assetplant.com	SM-MD25V	1980	400	200	350	1000	138	MT3
TitanMachinery.com.au	TM30V	2190	425	175	85	1100	180	MT3
www.standaco.com.au	DM-45	2200	500	230	120	1500	350	R8⁄MT4
www.machineryhouse.com.au	M143-HM45	2299	500	210	300	1100	350	MT3
www.minitech.com.au	X3	2310	300	145	85	600	136	R8⁄MT3
www.assetplant.com	SM-MD30V	2530	425	220	370	1100	210	MT3
TitanMachinery.com.au	TM45FG	2690	500	200	130	1500	440	R8
www.minitech.com.au	X5015M	2860	360	150	63	1100	265	R8

The bold two are my current picks - the cheapy is a generic X2 clone and it should take an X2 CNC kit out of the box (haven't tested it, but it looks like it). If not, the other two cheapies would be better.

Standco is a great recommendation, I was looking at the Titan before but this is cheaper and in Victoria. I've got to consult the finances but I'm keen to get one of these.

So, how's your conversion going?

[CADScott]

Another to consider is the BF20 Opti mill, which is $1400 from www.appliedmachinery.com.au, located in Dandenong. This is the same as the Opti BF20 sold in Germany, very nice machine, especially for the price.

[mozmozmoz]

Oooh, that's nice. It's the 500mm X travel that matters, since that's the most I've been able to find under $3k, and finding it on a $1400 mill is excellent. Where did you find the price though - I can't see it on their site and a search doesn't turn anything up.

thanks
Moz

[CADScott]

I went down and spoke to the salesman Tony, sorry forgot that that price is ex GST, but they will discount by 10% if you hassle them a bit.
I am looking to purchase one in a few weeks with another couple of people, and he offered us the 10% if we bought all three of them together.
It is a really nice machine, scraped ways, very smooth operation, variable speed DC motor up to 3000rpm and it comes with the stand included in the price.