View Full Version : Alternative to Ball Screw or Rack-n-Pinion


samualt
11-15-2004, 06:17 PM
Saw this and thought it might be interesting to some people. Its a kinky kind of rack-n-pinion, only different. They say it's Zero-Backlash! Check out Roller Pinion from Nexen (http://www.nexengroup.com/rp/). I may have to try one of these sometime just to see how well they work. Very unique!

arvidb
11-16-2004, 06:45 AM
Hey that thing is really cool! If you try it, be sure to report on it here. :) Any idea on the cost?

Arvid

samualt
11-16-2004, 12:59 PM
They don't have their prices listed. Does anyone? I call these "Stealth Products". Like so many other motion control specialists they don't list prices and want you to play phone/email tag with their sales staff before you find anything out. They said in their brochure it costs more than a rack system but less than a ball screw. Whatever that means.

Here is a brochure they gave me:
Roller Pinion Brochure, PDF - Adobe Acrobat Format (http://home.comcast.net/~kr4495/temp/RollerPinion.pdf)

Revised:
The Linear Distance Per Revolution of the thing is 6.3" for the smallest model - RPS16. That is about twice the length of a regular pinion gear, assuming you chose the smallest regular pinion. This just means you have some more stepping-down to do.

samualt
11-16-2004, 04:43 PM
Well, I got a reply from them on their smallest model. If you were going to make an axis that is around 60" long it would cost you about 1500 US after taxes and shipping. Around 3K for an 8 foot long x-axis (racks on both sides).
Is is definitely out of my league. But, it's still interesting even if I can't afford it.

:cheers:

blurrycustoms
02-24-2008, 11:57 PM
Anybody else have any experience with this system? Seems pretty expensive.

RICHARD ZASTROW
02-25-2008, 10:54 AM
This is a bit off-subject but Nexen has other interesting products as well. I have no connection with Nexen, I'm not their promoter.

Linear rail brakes, rotary brakes, the above roller gears among others.

Neat stuff but I haven't used any yet.

Dick Z

Zumba
02-26-2008, 05:55 PM
Is this new technology (as in last few years)? Seems like putting rollers on a pinion is something that engineers probably thought of decades ago. Does anyone else offer a roller pinion design?

Regardless, it is a very cool system. Ballscrews are impractical for large routers on low to medium budgets. Companies like Thermwood require support arms to prevent whip. Komo uses helical R&P. Bridge mills use massive ballscrews that probably cost more than high end routers.

Roller pinion... relatively inexpensive, easy to manufacture, lube-free. Pretty much the perfect linear drive system for woodworking IMO.

smannn
05-22-2008, 02:13 PM
I know there is a very smiliar gear in use, since 1999, at a General motors plant which is in use to stamp quarter panels in a linear motion application. I'm not a liberty to cast judgement but Nexen's technology is very similar to what is used in the GM plant. Infrindgements on current patents? But to answer you question, yes there are others out there that have this technology.