elaganis
04-12-2007, 06:56 PM
The following is my (and my co-workers) honest review of the machine so far that is both accurate, detailed and unexaggerated:
**Let me disregard all the BS our Vendor put us through with their lies, lack of knowledge, and poor response and just focus on the 3016FX machine.
1. I’ve used (to its limits) many machines such as Mazak, Brown and Sharp, older Fadals, Pratt and Whitney, and a couple of others. I currently use several Haas Machines and I am NO rookie when it comes to machines, their controllers, or operation. I must say this one ranks pretty low.
2. Build quality at first appearance is low. Paint quality is standard but all the exposed black oxide cap screws and button heads make the machine look like it has a disease. Almost everything about this machine screams cheap. Like seeing daylight thru the corners of the cabinet-which leak if you blast the coolant too hard. Or why not use lexan for removable side doors instead of sheet metal that rattles. None of the buttons light up (nope not the on/off). The cycle start and feed hold buttons are tiny keys on the keyboard and are on the opposite side of every machine I’ve ever used. Speaking of the buttons- CHEAP! They are nothing more then clear plastic caps snapped on top ink-jet printed labels. NO JOKE. Three of them fell off in the first day of typing. I had to glue those back in. (see attached pic.) The list goes on and on.
3. The controller w/this new data server is so new on this machine that Fadal in CA could not get me on my Network. I had to call, on my own of coarse, Fanuc support and try to get my $6800 worth of controller options working. I got worried when Fadal couldn’t tell me where the RJ45 plug was? I found it inside the operator’s panel (after removing 10 button head screws and sheet metal cover) behind the LCD screen mount. “OOP! Did we forget to move it to the outside of the machine?....or put a knock-out for it??” Needless to say after 8 hours of phone and IT support I was able to drop a 10meg file on the machine drive, which is just a 1gig flash card. I can test the surfacing, machine speed, look ahead, etc. Now the only problem, the data server is always dropping my connection (which done only through an FTP connection-silly). I have to reboot the machine to reconnect. Fadal has no clue and blames my network. Meanwhile my Haas machines run 100+meg surface program day and night as regular mapped network drive without fail.
4. Ok. So my program is there. Let me setup now. Tool offsets and G54 setting is just as archaic as the 1980s controllers. You may not have to enter the values or back figure manually anymore but getting to menus are a waste of keystrokes. Here is a good one! Want to load a tool? press two, not one, ½”x ½ ” square buttons on the controller and then stick your arm in the machine. There is no coolant proof button at the spindle (ie.Haas). Be careful those buttons have a delay.
5. The next tool button does not work nor does the manual coolant button. Fadal service is going to fix that.
6. Navigating the menus and controller is comical. I feel as if I’m in Apollo 13 but with a pretty color LCD screen. It’s 2007 people, do we still need to call things “FWD, RWD, PUNCH, READ, etc.” anymore? When’s the last time you saw a paper tape reel? Why so many blank fields? It makes tabbing thru menus more time consuming. I can’t use the cursors to scroll down the lists of almost anything. After all, this is your LATEST? I’d laugh but my wallets hurts too much.
7. WHY WHY WHY did Fadal combine the federate and Rapids control into one knob! This is not just stupid but dangerous. I was never a fan of the 120% max overrides on the spindle and federate to begin with but this horrible. Especially checking on drilling routines.
8. FYI, there is no door switch override parameter. Even though I was fooled by the button that said DOOR-OVRD, I broke a carbide end mill when the spindle and feed stop to check something. Nope that’s a useless button which I was told does not work that way.
9. Forget using the Manual guide i….it’s as intuitive as PC BIOS compared to Haas or Mazak systems. I can write G-code faster.
10. SO now let me cut a waffle surface as fast as I can. First with AI on and with AI off. It did, yay! Only took two full day of playing with this boat anchor. AI on: nice finish but slower than I thought-about 150in/min avg. AI off: OK finish, tolerance affected, of course as with any machine it stuttered. However I can’t get the machine to cut faster than 350in/min. Why? The service guy told me the machine was factory set to a max of 8900mm/min (about 350in/min) at all axis. YES, they did claim 800in/min in the brochure and there demo cuts at 500in/min (I don’t know if its real-my speed judgment is not that accurate from the video). Our Fadal vendor is looking into this.
11. Time to go home and fight this battle tomorrow. Shut the machine off. Wait? Why does it sound like it’s still on? That’s because none of the cooling fans ever turn off- EVER. They’ll last right up until my warranty goes at which point I’ll need to replace them on my dime. Hit the main breaker. What a sh*tty experience this has been. Did I just buy the YUGO of the machine tool world?
Bottom line: I made the wrong choice for us and what we do in this shop. I want a refund and should have bought something else.
Yours Truly
-E
**Let me disregard all the BS our Vendor put us through with their lies, lack of knowledge, and poor response and just focus on the 3016FX machine.
1. I’ve used (to its limits) many machines such as Mazak, Brown and Sharp, older Fadals, Pratt and Whitney, and a couple of others. I currently use several Haas Machines and I am NO rookie when it comes to machines, their controllers, or operation. I must say this one ranks pretty low.
2. Build quality at first appearance is low. Paint quality is standard but all the exposed black oxide cap screws and button heads make the machine look like it has a disease. Almost everything about this machine screams cheap. Like seeing daylight thru the corners of the cabinet-which leak if you blast the coolant too hard. Or why not use lexan for removable side doors instead of sheet metal that rattles. None of the buttons light up (nope not the on/off). The cycle start and feed hold buttons are tiny keys on the keyboard and are on the opposite side of every machine I’ve ever used. Speaking of the buttons- CHEAP! They are nothing more then clear plastic caps snapped on top ink-jet printed labels. NO JOKE. Three of them fell off in the first day of typing. I had to glue those back in. (see attached pic.) The list goes on and on.
3. The controller w/this new data server is so new on this machine that Fadal in CA could not get me on my Network. I had to call, on my own of coarse, Fanuc support and try to get my $6800 worth of controller options working. I got worried when Fadal couldn’t tell me where the RJ45 plug was? I found it inside the operator’s panel (after removing 10 button head screws and sheet metal cover) behind the LCD screen mount. “OOP! Did we forget to move it to the outside of the machine?....or put a knock-out for it??” Needless to say after 8 hours of phone and IT support I was able to drop a 10meg file on the machine drive, which is just a 1gig flash card. I can test the surfacing, machine speed, look ahead, etc. Now the only problem, the data server is always dropping my connection (which done only through an FTP connection-silly). I have to reboot the machine to reconnect. Fadal has no clue and blames my network. Meanwhile my Haas machines run 100+meg surface program day and night as regular mapped network drive without fail.
4. Ok. So my program is there. Let me setup now. Tool offsets and G54 setting is just as archaic as the 1980s controllers. You may not have to enter the values or back figure manually anymore but getting to menus are a waste of keystrokes. Here is a good one! Want to load a tool? press two, not one, ½”x ½ ” square buttons on the controller and then stick your arm in the machine. There is no coolant proof button at the spindle (ie.Haas). Be careful those buttons have a delay.
5. The next tool button does not work nor does the manual coolant button. Fadal service is going to fix that.
6. Navigating the menus and controller is comical. I feel as if I’m in Apollo 13 but with a pretty color LCD screen. It’s 2007 people, do we still need to call things “FWD, RWD, PUNCH, READ, etc.” anymore? When’s the last time you saw a paper tape reel? Why so many blank fields? It makes tabbing thru menus more time consuming. I can’t use the cursors to scroll down the lists of almost anything. After all, this is your LATEST? I’d laugh but my wallets hurts too much.
7. WHY WHY WHY did Fadal combine the federate and Rapids control into one knob! This is not just stupid but dangerous. I was never a fan of the 120% max overrides on the spindle and federate to begin with but this horrible. Especially checking on drilling routines.
8. FYI, there is no door switch override parameter. Even though I was fooled by the button that said DOOR-OVRD, I broke a carbide end mill when the spindle and feed stop to check something. Nope that’s a useless button which I was told does not work that way.
9. Forget using the Manual guide i….it’s as intuitive as PC BIOS compared to Haas or Mazak systems. I can write G-code faster.
10. SO now let me cut a waffle surface as fast as I can. First with AI on and with AI off. It did, yay! Only took two full day of playing with this boat anchor. AI on: nice finish but slower than I thought-about 150in/min avg. AI off: OK finish, tolerance affected, of course as with any machine it stuttered. However I can’t get the machine to cut faster than 350in/min. Why? The service guy told me the machine was factory set to a max of 8900mm/min (about 350in/min) at all axis. YES, they did claim 800in/min in the brochure and there demo cuts at 500in/min (I don’t know if its real-my speed judgment is not that accurate from the video). Our Fadal vendor is looking into this.
11. Time to go home and fight this battle tomorrow. Shut the machine off. Wait? Why does it sound like it’s still on? That’s because none of the cooling fans ever turn off- EVER. They’ll last right up until my warranty goes at which point I’ll need to replace them on my dime. Hit the main breaker. What a sh*tty experience this has been. Did I just buy the YUGO of the machine tool world?
Bottom line: I made the wrong choice for us and what we do in this shop. I want a refund and should have bought something else.
Yours Truly
-E